Blog

China balloon: Could it have been blown off course as Beijing claims?

The Chinese authorities say a surveillance balloon sighted over sensitive US territory is theirs, but insist its purpose is for weather research and that it was blown off course by unexpected winds.

We've looked at the prevailing wind patterns and data modelling to track its possible path. Chinese Meteorological Balloon

China balloon: Could it have been blown off course as Beijing claims?

It was monitored travelling across Canadian territory before appearing over the city of Billings in Montana on Wednesday, where it was spotted in the sky by city residents.

US authorities say they've been tracking the balloon across US airspace using manned aircraft, and that it's been flying over sensitive military areas.

China says strong "westerlies" blew the device "with limited self-steering capability" off its planned course.

BBC Weather's Simon King says that in the north Pacific between China and North America, the prevailing winds are westerlies (that is, from west towards the east).

"In recent days, the wind speeds above an altitude of 30,000 to 40,000ft (9,000 to 12,000m) were 150mph (240km/h) or above in this area of the Pacific," he says. "There is nothing unusual about wind speeds this high in this area."

The wind patterns in the north Pacific in the past few days would have blown the balloon north-east to Alaska and then south-east through Canada to Montana, he says.

"Most weather balloons rise to about 100,000ft and then blow apart after a few hours, with the equipment falling to Earth by parachute. It is unusual for a weather balloon to last days like this."

Dr Marina Miron, researcher in defence studies at Kings College London says the balloon might have been more sophisticated than China claims.

"The balloon could be controlled remotely by an operator on the ground," she says. "They'd be able to raise or lower the altitude of the balloon so that it could pick up different wind currents which are going in different directions.

"You would want to be able to make it linger over a spot to collect data. This is something you can do with balloon which you cannot do with a satellite."

Not with any certainty. We don't have flight tracking data that we would for commercial airliner, for example, so we need to look to other sources of information.

One technique used to estimate the path of high-altitude particles or objects is to use a model based on wind speeds and direction.

The National Oceanic and Atmospheric US department (NOAA) has developed such a model (known as HYSPLIT) based on winds at altitudes over 14,000m (46,000ft).

"Its primary use," says Simon King from BBC Weather, "is for working out the transport and dispersion of things such as pollutants and hazardous material in the atmosphere.

"The model also works backwards - called back trajectory - where we can see where anything carried in the air such as pollutants, ash or other material has come from.

"In the case of the balloon over the US, this back trajectory can show where the air carrying the balloon originated from and by analysing wind direction and speed, where it'll go in the future."

US meteorologist Dan Satterfield has used this model to calculate a possible route the surveillance balloon has taken, and has shared his findings online.

Starting from the position sighted in Montana on 1 February, he has estimated a possible back trajectory for the balloon, based on wind data, originating in central China.

It must be stressed that this is not the actual path the surveillance balloon has taken, but an analysis based on the model developed by NOAA, a US government agency.

In January the prime minister said five priorities should be used to hold his government to account.

The chancellor will confirm how much benefits will go up in the Autumn Statement.

"Alice" speaks exclusively to the BBC after her successful lawsuit against Omegle forced it offline.

Prosecutors accused Harrison Floyd, ex-head of Black Voices for Trump, of trying to intimidate witnesses.

More than 4,800 flights were behind schedule as rain and strong winds buffeted the US east coast.

Copyright 2023 BBC. All rights reserved.  The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.

Beta Terms By using the Beta Site, you agree that such use is at your own risk and you know that the Beta Site may include known or unknown bugs or errors, that we have no obligation to make this Beta Site available with or without charge for any period of time, nor to make it available at all, and that nothing in these Beta Terms or your use of the Beta Site creates any employment relationship between you and us. The Beta Site is provided on an “as is” and “as available” basis and we make no warranty to you of any kind, express or implied.

China balloon: Could it have been blown off course as Beijing claims?

Hwoyee 3000g Meteorological Balloon In case of conflict between these Beta Terms and the BBC Terms of Use these Beta Terms shall prevail.